Make sure to book in advance
The Reykjavik EDITION - most luxurious hotel in Reykjavik
The Retreat at Blue Lagoon Iceland - expensive but amazing
Hotel Geysir
Skálakot Hotel
Umi Hotel
Deplar Farm- if it wasn’t so expensive it would be #1 on list
Hótel Húsafell
Hótel Flatey
Hótel Búðir
Gistihúsið - Lake Hótel Egilsstaðir - great spot in East Iceland. I love staying in Egilsstadir because of location. Food is great here too